Showing posts with label Fielding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fielding. Show all posts

Thursday, 24 July 2014

Patching

I was recently listening to a cricket podcast. The expert panel was asked about the benefits of vision training, especially for late developers. The experts agreed that generalised vision training was of little use, except possibly as a psychological boost. Vision training that was done in the context of the sport, however, might be helpful. Needless to say, those views echo my own precisely.


One coach said that it could be useful to patch one eye when practising bowling, batting or fielding. He has got his batsmen on occasion to wear a patch over what he called the “motor eye”, which is the eye that leads when we are tracking a moving object. The idea was that this would “strengthen” the other eye. I think he was on stronger ground when he suggested that because this was putting his batsmen in a challenging position, so it would help them deal with other difficult situations that they might encounter in a match, which is why his players found it both challenging and useful. I’m certainly all for making practice highly demanding, so that you are mentally and physically prepared for the challenged that will come your way on match day.
                  
I was reminded of an experiment on eye dominance and tennis that I’ve discussed before. It was found that blurring the non-dominant eye of elite tennis players had a deleterious effect on performance, whereas fogging the dominant eye did not. This rather paradoxical finding was explained by suggesting that the non-dominant eye was essential for depth perception. Whilst this may well be true, I’m no longer sure that it explains the findings as the dominant eye must also be essential for really accurate depth perception.
                  
I therefore suspect that what happened in these tennis players was the same as happened to the cricketers: when the dominant eye was blurred, it felt really strange, so the players had to concentrate harder on the ball. In doing so, they were able to perceive monocular cues such as image size, which meant that their depth perception wasn’t actually too badly affected. When the non-dominant eye was blurred, however, because the effect on vision was less noticeable, they made little or no adjustment for it.
                  
So, patching the dominant eye can be a useful exercise, but it probably needs to be used sparingly. It’s likely to result in adjustments to the body, such as a head tilt. If a player doesn’t have really strong eye dominance, they could start switching during competition, and if they don’t make the necessary compensatory adjustments their timing and other judgements could be all wrong.
                  
I’m not sure how this relates to late developers, but I suspect it depends on why they are developing late. It could help with getting them to concentrate on the ball as it leaves the bowler’s hand, or help them get into line better. But if they are late developers because they haven’t played much cricket, you would probably be better leaving them to work this out for themselves. If the idea is to make the practice more challenging, there are other ways of doing this, such as using smaller balls and/or bats, or getting them to read markings on the ball as it approaches.
                  
Patching can be useful in a number of sports. In golf, for instance, it could be used to ensure that the player maintains eye dominance when switching from the ball to the target. In rugby, you might notice that some players are not paying enough attention to the passer’s hands as he passes the ball. This means that they are late in reacting to the ball as it appears in front of them and therefore drop it. One solution would be to patch the left eye for passes coming from their left, and the right eye for passes coming from their right. This would then require them to turn their head towards the passer so they pick up the flight of the ball at the earliest stage. I would probably still be inclined to achieve a similar effect by using smaller balls, balls of a dull colour that are harder to see, or balls with numbers or letters on that the players have to read out before they catch them.
                  
Patching both eyes, otherwise known as blindfolding, certainly has a place for enhancing kinaesthetic feedback. But that’s for another day.

David Donner

Friday, 3 January 2014

The A - Z of Sports Vision - Tau

Hofsten (1983) videotaped infants between 34 and 36 weeks as they reached out towards a brightly-coloured object travelling in a circle. In 144 reaches, they only missed 17 times, and the mean timing error was just 4.4ms when the object travelled at 45cm/second. McLeod, McLaughlin & Nimmo-Smith (1986) asked non-games players to hit vertically-dropping squash balls towards a target with a bat. They were extraordinarily consistent, with standard deviations of just 10ms in 90% of trials, and only 5ms in 50% of trials. So “ordinary people” can demonstrate fine timing even without any particular practice. How do we manage these extraordinary calculations? The answer is that we don’t calculate them. Suppose you are a fielding on the boundary in cricket and the ball has been hit in the air towards you. To calculate the balls arrival (Time-to-Contact or Tc), you’d have to estimate the distance the ball has to travel and its speed, and then divide one by the other. This doesn’t seem a likely method for adults, let alone infants. Lee (1976) proposed that the time to contact could be assessed by using changes to the size of the image that an object creates on retina as it approaches. For our fielder in the deep, the ball approaches him at a fairly constant speed. But when it’s far away, the size of image it forms on the retina doesn’t change much. As it gets nearer, however, the image size gets larger at an increasing rate. The ratio between the image size and the rate of expansion of that image size is known as tau (it’s actually the ratio of visual angle of rate of change of visual angle, but you get the idea). Tau can be used to predict the time at which an object travelling at a constant speed will reach us, and therefore the time at which we need to instigate a movement to intercept it. In a brilliant experiment, Savelsbergh et al (1991) got subjects to catch a ball one-handed. But the ball actually consisted of a small ball 5.5cm in diameter surrounded by an inflatable balloon 7.5cm in diameter. As the balloon approached the catcher it was mechanically deflated without he catcher’s knowledge, so by the time it reached the catcher’s hand it was the same diameter as the small ball. The ball was travelling at a constant velocity, so if the catchers were using that velocity to judge when the ball would arrive, they should still catch it. But because the ball was deflating, the ball’s image on the retina did not expand at the expected rate, so the catchers were late in their attempts to intercept the ball. This proved that the catchers were using tau when catching. Of course for the fielder on the boundary the ball isn’t coming in a straight line, it’s in a parabola, and the fielder may well have to run laterally to get to it. There are other visual strategies that can be used for successful catching, but that’s for another blog. David Donner

Wednesday, 2 June 2010

Sports Vision - Fielding in Cricket

A ball is travelling towards you. How do you know when it’s going to arrive, so you can get your hands in the right position to catch it? Muscles in the hand must be prepared so that the hand is widest open before the ball hits just above the palm (ideally), the wrist forearm and elbow must be prepared to absorb the kinetic energy of the ball, and the finger joints must also be prepared to close around the ball after impact. Muscle responses need to start about 100 milliseconds before the ball arrives.

From physics, the time taken for the ball to arrive will be its distance away from you divided by the speed at which it’s travelling. The brain can deduce information about the ball’s position from the size of its image on the retina; the smaller the image, the further away it is. The rate at which the image is getting bigger tells the brain how fast the ball is coming towards you (i.e. its speed).

The brain doesn’t actually calculate the ratio between them, but it knows, through practice, that when this ratio reaches a critical level, it’s time to send the necessary messages to the arm and hand muscles.

Savelsbergh et al conducted an interesting experiment in 1991 using a balloon that deflated as it approached the catcher. Because the image size on the retina did not increase as normal, the catchers overestimated the time to contact, showing that they were using image size for their timing rather than just the speed of the ball. The effect was most noticeable when one eye was covered. It was still there when both eyes were open, but less so, suggesting that stereoscopic information from vision can also be used.

This is fine for a ball that’s travelling at a steady speed, but what about a ball that’s accelerating? An outfielder under a skied catch has to deal with a ball that’s dropping at a rate of 32 ft/sec², and they may have to run to get in line with it as well.

If the fielder is directly under a skier, the brain can use something known as the “zeta angle”. This is the apparent size of a falling object relative to its apparent size at the moment the object started to fall. If it can make an allowance for gravity, the brain can initiate the catching actions when the zeta angle reaches a certain level, as long as the point when the ball started to drop was observed.

Experiments on astronauts on board Space Shuttle Columbia have shown that we do indeed make an adjustment for the effect of gravity. In space, the astronauts were too early in their attempts to catch the ball, because their brains were programmed to take into account the effect of a non-existent gravity.

If the ball is coming straight to the fielder, then his angle of gaze – the angle between the eye and the ball – will remain constant. If it’s not coming straight at him, then the angle of gaze will vary as the ball travels. The brain can use this information by trying to keep the angle constant or within a certain range. This information will get enable the catch to be made (assuming the fielder can run fast enough). The brain doesn’t calculate where the ball will land: it just uses the visual information to get the fielder to where the ball will land.

Finally, the fielder needs to be in a position where the ball appears to be travelling at a constant speed. If it’s speeding up, you need to move back, or move forward if it appears to be slowing down.

The unsurprising conclusion from all of this is that the more experience of catching from a young age that one gets, the better.


For more information please visit http://www.donneroptometrists.co.uk/sports-vision.htm